How you react defines who you become

(This is a classic story that I have used in training and motivational materials for about 10 years now…and every once in awhile, a friend or client’s reaction to something makes me think of it again…I do not know the original author.)

Carrots, Eggs, or Coffee

A young woman went to her mother and told her about her life and how things were so hard for her. She did not know how she was going to make it and wanted to give up She was tired of fighting and struggling. It seemed as one problem was solved, a new one arose.

Her mother took her to the kitchen. She filled three pots with water and placed each on a high fire. Soon the pots came to boil.

  • In the first she placed carrots.
  • In the second she placed eggs
  • In the last she placed ground coffee beans.

She let them sit and boil; without saying a word.

In about twenty minutes she turned off the burners.

  • She fished the carrots out and placed them in a bowl.
  • She pulled the eggs out and placed them in a bowl.
  • She ladled the coffee out and placed it in a bowl.

Turning to her daughter, she asked, “Tell me what you see.”

“Carrots, eggs, and coffee,” she replied.

Her mother brought her closer and asked her to feel the carrots. She did and noted that they were soft. The mother then asked the daughter to take an egg and break it. After pulling off the shell, she observed the hard-boiled egg.

Finally, the mother asked the daughter to sip the coffee. The daughter smiled, as she tasted its rich aroma the daughter then asked, “What are you trying to say, mother?”

Her mother explained that each of these objects had faced the same adversity: boiling water. Yet wach reacted differently.

The carrot went in strong, hard, and unrelenting. However, after being subjected to the boiling water, it softened and became weak.

The egg had been fragile. Its thin outer shell had protected its liquid interior, but after sitting through the boiling water, its insides became hardened.

The ground coffee beans were unique, however. After they were in the boiling water, they had changed the water.

And then she asked her daughter….

“When adversity knocks on your door, how do you respond? Are you a carrot, an egg or a coffee bean?

** Note from Carrie: I don’t know that I need to add anything to this – but would love to know some things in the comment section below that help you when you are up against obstacles & adversity.  And as always, please share with your social networks if you found this helpful at all.

  • Trisha Philbrook

    Wow!  What a great story.  I’m kind of speechless, but I will be sharing it with my social network. 

  • http://www.enmast.com/ Brad Farris

    In adversity Michael Hyatt asks the question, “What does this make possible?” I’ve been using that a lot to reframe challenges that come my way.  

    I have another friend who taught me to stop saying, “I have to …” and instead to say “I get to …” That language shift has made a big impact on me too.

    I’ll have to think more about the coffee – but I like how it is affecting the water, not being affected like the carrot and egg.

  • http://www.facebook.com/dave.baldwin77 Dave Baldwin

    The real question “boils down to” this…how does one go about becoming something different; I believe it is possible for anyone to be a carrot and later become an egg/coffee, but that this transition requires the right kinds of habits/practices over time.

  • http://www.facebook.com/dave.baldwin77 Dave Baldwin

    The real question “boils down to” this…how does one go about becoming something different; I believe it is possible for anyone to be a carrot and later become an egg/coffee, but that this transition requires the right kinds of habits/practices over time.

  • Gene Boyd

    WOW! That’s the first time I’ve heard that story. Thank you for sharing. I’ll gladly share it, and never forget it. Thanks again!

  • http://seekoutwisdom.blogspot.com Joseph Iliff of SeekOutWisdom

    I love the example of the ground coffee beans. They responded to the adversity of the hot water to make something wonderful. But then, I am a coffee lover. I try to remember that adversity and challenge are opportunities to become stronger and wiser. How I respond to them can cause me to grow and achieve more than I could before. If I don’t achieve, I know more about myself and my abilities, growing in wisdom. Either way, I am better because of it. Steel must be tempered by fire to be forged into a sword.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1098345294 Karleen Harp

    What a great analogy.  We’d all like to think we are coffee, but I think most of us are a little of each at different times.  Changing the catalyst for change itself is hard to do!  I think I’m often an egg, and occasionally coffee.

  • http://www.facebook.com/katrinamariethibodeau Katrina Marie

    If you were to boil the water longer…the carrot would change the water into a vegetable soup base that could then be added to nicely. The egg may need some special handling, but it could also change the water into a lovely egg drop soup. I see them as all the same, just requiring different methods of preparation to become the final creation. I think we each take different approaches in how we build our businesses, some may require more time and careful planning, while others can just boil the water, and be out the door. Also, with the carrot and egg the creation is editable and healthy, but the coffee beans they have to be throw away.

  • Carrie Wilkerson

     I love reframing…you know this is how I function daily… in the REFRAME ;)

  • Carrie Wilkerson

    Katrina – I think you are taking something totally different away from the story than I am. But that’s the genius of critical thinking :)

    Clearly you can do something great with each of those things, but the mother was communicating to her daughter you can soften, harden or change your surroundings. (the lemons into lemonade or carrots into soup example are a whole different lesson ;)

    I’m not sure ANY business can just ‘boil the water’ and be out the door with successful results. This was more a character example than a business builder lesson. Sorry if I was unclear.

  • Carrie Wilkerson

     I think sometimes we ‘egg up’ in order to protect ourselves from hurt. It’s human nature, I suppose ;)

  • Carrie Wilkerson

     the refiner’s fire! exactly!

  • Carrie Wilkerson

     Dave, I believe we are likely different things at different times. In relationships, perhaps we trend towards softening or hardening, whereas in business, we are consistently coffee. I think the key point is to be self aware that you can allow things to change you (reactively) or you can change things around you (proactively)

  • Marcia Blenman

    Can be a bit of the three, just depends, right now I am a corrot. Where are the people with the strength you need for theese times that seems to have no end. May be Four years ago I was a coffee bean for sure, never would I have seen mysef a carrot.

  • http://wisdomweightlossprogram.com/ SkinnyandFabulous

    I knew you loved coffee. Now I know why! :)

  • http://www.walthampton.com/ Walt Hampton

    The words we use in any situation create our reality. The Chinese symbol for danger also means opportunity. In each moment we get to choose how we will be. Thank you for a wonderful reminder.

  • Carrie Wilkerson

     in other news…saw a shirt today that said ‘strong is the new skinny’ – LOVED that — you should have one ;)

  • Carrie Wilkerson

     I think we have seasons Marcia. Surround yourself with coffee folks to help you when you aren’t feeling very strong on your own!

  • Joe@abalauction.com

    Co co ca cho I am a Walrus. No wait, now  am a coffee bean. Booyah on a great story. I knew I was related to Juan Valdez

  • Joel Carter

    This reminds me of Mark Twain who used animals to tell a story.The method of comparing human traits to those of fruit, vegetables,grain, minerals, animals or other, nonhuman object lessons are much more effective and memorable.

  • Nocateman

    honestly, sometimes I can be either depending on the moment. family matters with my outlaws and inlaws=hard boiled egg.  wife issues=mushy carrots work issues=hard boiled egg . spiritual issues =God is my coffee.

  • http://socialposer.com/ Collin

    I needed this today. Thanks Carrie!

  • Carrie Wilkerson

    My first blog Booyah. Lol

  • Carrie Wilkerson

    Perhaps because we can be more objectives when we remove the human element?

  • Alex Theis

    Great story on a day I really needed to hear it. Leaders rise to the occasion and influence others. Thanks Carrie.

  • kelly papotto

    Great analogy. Our youth is like the coffee bean that inspires us to pursue our day to day. Time is essential and It is important to examine ourselves and circumstances. This article made me laugh and think.

  • http://twitter.com/loafandlearn loafandlearn

    Such a simple elegant story. Getting into hot water will change you.  Pay attention to how.

    You can take the metaphor on too, the water is changed yes because of the coffee. The coffee has changed state, developed into something different, evolvedI was thinking about tea ( I am British) similar thing happens but the tea can take another batch of hot water… not that it wants to necessarily :-) I agree too we will respond differently each time, I think the hotwater speaks of resilience, we do not always know when we enter the water how hot it is going to get.

  • CarolynGill

    I’ve actually, oddly, some to APPRECIATE the boiling water, because I LOVE the RESULTS.  

  • http://www.carolyngill.com/ Carolyn Gill

    I just read a really interesting fact about the inner lining of the egg, the membrane.  If you take the membrane skin out and apply it to a wound, it will close the wound, and stop it from bleeding.  Now, isn’t that cool, the God has even given us a way to protect us when it seems like all we can do is break.  Even the broke shell, brings healing. 

  • http://www.enmast.com/ Brad Farris

    You should check out “Your Brain at Work” he’s got a big section on tools for reframing. It’s an all around excellent book, but the reframing section is excellent.

  • http://twitter.com/TheJohnBudnik John Budnik

    This made me feel a bit like Homer and his donuts.  All I could think of was “Mmm coffee”.  Off to grab my afternoon cup of Joe. 

  • http://www.relationshipyogi.com/ Steven Manus

    We can change the way we respond, first by getting a sense of our tendencies, and then redirecting the energy toward a more positive end. The world around us will respond as our energy changes.

  • The Lollipop Tree

    Yes and if we’re not careful we can be gradually boiled to death like the frog without realising it.

  • Molokai Roots 808

    I loved this story!!  I often use the same techniques to teach my 3 girls whom are 11, 12 and 13.  Having children that age, SEE while you’re teaching, makes it easier for them to understand.  It sure was a great lesson to me as well- been struggling through a few “speed bumps” myself, and they’ve been coming almost never-ending.  In the end, it boils down to one thing, “the way we see our trials, and the way we deal with them”.  Thanks for sharing that, object lesson!! AWESOME!

  • Tracey Smith

    What doesn’t kill us makes us stronger!  Loved the story and sharing on my social networks right now!

  • MariaE

    No you put them in the soil under the roses. :)

  • MariaE

    Thank you Carrie. I will share this with the people I know who are looking for work and sometimes don’t realize. How great they are even thru the challenges. 

  • http://memorybuilder101.com/ Azdee

    And, like tea, you don’t know how strong you are until you’ve put put in hot water!

  • http://twitter.com/AppsMirror AppsMirror

    Very classic explanation and  interesting to read.

  • Simba

    Yes we are what we are because of what we went through.

  • Felicia Fields

    Phenomenal analogy! I AM INDEED A COFFEE BEAN! Thank you Carrie for sharing your story and your wisdom! Felicia Fields…see you soon (at the TOP) :-)

  • http://www.wickedlychic.com/ wickedlychic

    Great minds think alike! Someone else – also a Texan :) – shared this story and I published it in Wickedly Chic last month. Love it.